The Indiana Normal Meeting not too long ago handed Senate Enrolled Act No. 475 (“SEA 475”), which can ban new noncompete agreements between physicians and coated well being care entities entered into on or after July 1, 2025. Governor Braun is predicted to signal the invoice. As defined additional beneath, the noncompete ban applies to hospitals, hospital methods, father or mother corporations and affiliated managers of a hospital.
Overview
During the last a number of years, the Indiana Normal Meeting has handed a sequence of legal guidelines limiting doctor noncompete agreements. In 2023, for instance, Senate Enrolled Act No. 7 prohibited newly entered noncompete agreements with main care physicians. An earlier regulation required inclusion of a “buyout” provision in contracts with physicians, permitting the doctor to keep away from enforcement of the noncompete in change for paying the employer an affordable quantity. SEA 475 provides a number of new sections throughout the doctor noncompete settlement provisions of Title 25 of the Indiana Code.
Which Well being Care Entities Are Lined?
Starting July 1, 2025, the next well being care entities might not enter into noncompete agreements with physicians:
- a hospital, as outlined in Indiana Code 16-18-2-179(b);
- a father or mother firm of a hospital;
- an affiliated supervisor of a hospital; or
- a hospital system.
The time period “hospital system” is outlined as: (i) a father or mother company of a minimum of one hospital and any entity affiliated with the father or mother company by possession, governance or membership; or (ii) a hospital and any affiliated entity with the hospital by possession, governance or membership. Notably, this noncompete ban doesn’t apply to different doctor employers, reminiscent of personal practices or non-hospital/non-hospital system-owned doctor teams.
Who Is a Lined Doctor, and What Is the Observe of Medication?
Not like Indiana’s prior noncompete ban, which solely prohibited noncompete agreements with main care physicians no matter employer kind, SEA 475 doesn’t make that distinction. Slightly, it prohibits any coated entity from having a noncompete prohibiting the “observe of medication” with any doctor licensed to observe drugs or osteopathic drugs in Indiana.
The time period “doctor” is outlined in Indiana Code 25-22.5-1-1.1(g) and means “any one that holds the diploma of physician of medication or physician of osteopathy or its equal and who holds a sound limitless license to observe drugs or osteopathic drugs in Indiana.” Notably, the brand new regulation doesn’t apply to doctor assistants or superior observe suppliers.
The time period “observe of medication” is outlined in Indiana Code 25-22.5-1-1.1(a) and (b). As clarified within the new regulation, “observe of medication” doesn’t embrace actions that: (i) are solely and completely government or managerial and (ii) don’t contain direct affected person care.
What Is a “Noncompete Settlement”?
SEA 475 broadly defines “noncompete settlement” as:
“[A] contract, or any a part of a contract, to which a doctor is a celebration that has the aim or impact of limiting or penalizing a doctor’s means to have interaction within the observe of medication in any geographic space, for any time frame, after the doctor’s employment relationship with a hospital, a father or mother firm of a hospital, an affiliated supervisor of a hospital, or a hospital system has ended.”
The regulation supplies the next examples of prohibited noncompete agreements:
- Provisions that prohibit the doctor from participating within the observe of medication with a brand new employer;
- Provisions that impose monetary penalties, compensation obligations or require reimbursement of bonuses, coaching bills or comparable funds that:
- are utilized after a minimum of three years of employment; and
- are primarily based solely or totally on the doctor’s choice to proceed participating within the observe of medication with a brand new employer;
- Provisions requiring the doctor to acquire the employer’s consent or undergo equitable aid; and
- Provisions imposing oblique restrictions that restrict or deter the doctor’s observe of medication with a brand new employer.
The regulation clarifies that the next are not thought of noncompete agreements:
- Nondisclosure agreements that defend confidential enterprise info or commerce secrets and techniques;
- Nonsolicitation agreements limiting the solicitation of present workers for one yr after employment ends (as long as they don’t prohibit affected person interactions, referrals, scientific collaboration or skilled relationships); and
- Noncompete agreements entered into as a part of a sale of a enterprise entity the place the doctor owns greater than 50% of the entity on the time of sale.
Curiously, the regulation doesn’t explicitly deal with affected person nonsolicitation agreements, a generally used restrictive covenant within the well being care trade. Nonetheless, the broad definition of “noncompete settlement” might arguably prohibit affected person nonsolicitation agreements relying on particular info and circumstances.
Essential Timing Issues
As acknowledged above, SEA 475 doesn’t go into impact till July 1, 2025. It additionally clarifies that noncompete agreements entered into earlier than July 1, 2025, won’t be invalidated, even when renewed or amended after that date.
Different States Passing Related Legal guidelines
With the passage of SEA 475, Indiana joins Maryland, Pennsylvania and Louisiana amongst states which have not too long ago handed legal guidelines limiting noncompetes for well being care-related professions. Greater than 10 different states have already got legal guidelines that prohibit or considerably restrict doctor noncompete agreements.
Sensible Takeaways
Indiana hospitals and affiliated entities can now not depend on noncompete agreements to guard enterprise pursuits and retain physicians (and, by extension, their affected person bases). Hospitals ought to assessment and revise all template agreements used when recruiting and hiring new physicians, together with employment agreements, recruitment agreements and bonus or incentive preparations containing clawback provisions.
Hospitals must also implement new methods to reinforce doctor retention, specializing in making a superior employment expertise and turning into an employer of alternative. Strengthening relationships with sufferers and communities may also be more and more necessary.
Please be part of Corridor Render attorneys for a webinar within the coming weeks, which can present further particulars relating to each the authorized and sensible concerns of SEA 475.
When you have any questions in regards to the subjects mentioned on this publish, please contact:
Corridor Render weblog posts and articles are supposed for informational functions solely. For moral causes, Corridor Render attorneys can not give authorized recommendation exterior of an attorney-client relationship.